**

China's economic slowdown, persistent trade imbalances, and reliance on state-owned enterprises continue to fuel debates about whether it's truly "winning" the trade war, even after the signing of the Phase One trade deal in 2020. While some argue that China has successfully navigated the economic fallout of the US-China trade war, a closer examination reveals a more nuanced and concerning picture for the Chinese economy. This article delves into the key reasons why China is still losing the long-term battle, despite some short-term gains.

The Lingering Impact of Tariffs and Trade Restrictions

The US-China trade war, initiated in 2018, involved the imposition of significant tariffs on billions of dollars worth of goods traded between the two nations. While the Phase One deal offered some tariff reductions, many remain in place, creating ongoing friction and uncertainty. These tariffs haven't simply vanished. They have increased the cost of Chinese exports to the US, impacting competitiveness and profitability for many Chinese businesses, especially in sectors like manufacturing and agriculture.

Impact on Chinese Exports:

• Reduced competitiveness: Higher tariffs make Chinese goods more expensive, rendering them less attractive to US consumers compared to alternatives from other countries. This is particularly relevant for goods with readily available substitutes.
• Supply chain disruptions: The trade war forced businesses to reconsider their supply chains, leading to diversification away from China for some US companies. This shift is a long-term challenge for China to overcome.
• Investment hesitation: The uncertainty created by the trade war has discouraged foreign direct investment (FDI) in China, slowing economic growth and hindering technological advancements.

China's Economic Slowdown and its Interplay with the Trade War

Beyond the direct impact of tariffs, China’s overall economic slowdown significantly complicates the narrative of a “trade war victory.” Factors like a weakening real estate sector, debt accumulation, and a demographic crisis are creating headwinds that are independent of the trade war but exacerbate its effects.

Weakening Real Estate Market:

The collapse of Evergrande and other real estate giants has sent shockwaves through the Chinese economy, impacting construction, employment, and consumer confidence. This downturn, coupled with the lingering effects of trade restrictions, further dampens economic growth.

Debt Accumulation and Financial Risks:

China's high level of corporate and government debt remains a major concern. The trade war has only increased the pressure on indebted companies, pushing some toward insolvency and exacerbating the overall financial risk. This creates a vicious cycle – reducing investment, growth, and exports.

Technological Dependence and the "Innovation Gap"

The trade war highlighted China's continued reliance on imported technology, particularly in semiconductors. The US restrictions on technology exports have exposed China's vulnerability in key technological areas, stressing the importance of self-reliance in critical sectors. This “innovation gap” is a long-term challenge that requires significant investment and technological breakthroughs.

Impact on Semiconductors and Tech:

• US restrictions: The US has imposed restrictions on the sale of advanced semiconductor technology to China, limiting its access to essential components for various industries.
• Domestic development challenges: While China is investing heavily in domestic semiconductor production, it faces significant hurdles in catching up with the technological advancements of the US and other leading nations. This is a multi-decade project.

The Role of State-Owned Enterprises (SOEs)

China's reliance on state-owned enterprises (SOEs) presents another challenge. While these enterprises play a crucial role in the Chinese economy, their efficiency and competitiveness are often debated. The trade war has exposed some of their limitations in adapting to the dynamic global market.

SOE Inefficiencies:

• Lack of market responsiveness: SOEs, often shielded from market forces, may struggle to adapt quickly to changing market conditions and the challenges presented by the trade war.
• Subsidies and unfair competition: Allegations of state subsidies to SOEs have fueled criticism, suggesting that their success isn't solely based on market competitiveness.

The Future of US-China Trade Relations: A Long-Term Perspective

The Phase One trade deal offered a temporary reprieve, but it didn’t resolve the underlying tensions between the two economic giants. The long-term implications of the trade war remain significant, and the possibility of further escalations cannot be discounted.

Ongoing Tensions:

• Technological rivalry: Competition in key technological sectors, such as artificial intelligence, 5G, and semiconductors, remains a major point of contention.
• Intellectual property rights: Concerns about intellectual property theft and forced technology transfer continue to be a significant obstacle.

Conclusion: The Trade War's Enduring Impact

While China has demonstrated resilience in navigating the economic challenges posed by the trade war, the argument that it has “won” is misleading. The lingering impact of tariffs, China's economic slowdown, technological vulnerabilities, and reliance on SOEs paint a more complex and concerning picture. The US-China trade relationship remains fraught with tensions, and the long-term consequences of the trade war will undoubtedly continue to shape the global economic landscape for years to come. The ultimate outcome of this prolonged trade friction is far from settled and will depend on future policy decisions, technological advancements, and the adaptability of both economies. It's a battle for economic dominance that is far from over.